How To Configure My Monitor To True Color For Photographys Benq

by -46 views

Broad Gamut BenQ Monitor…what does color manner on monitor do & question re: saturation variations?

I have a BenQ SW2700PT and am wondering what switching between the color manner on the actual monitor does. I know that in order to change a colour infinite, I demand to alter the color style on the monitor itself and also change the default ICC profile in my color management settings. I also understand, I hope correctly that my colour managed software uses the ICC profile every bit a sort of translator for color, but I’m at a loss to understand what the role of the color way on the monitor itself is.

On a very basic level, if I printing the buttons on the lesser of my monitor and cull the default Adobe RGB and then go into my color management settings on my calculator and choose ICC contour Adobe RGB 1998, what is the monitor part doing? Is it that the ICC contour tells Photoshop how to translate and the color mode of the monitor tells the monitor to translate?

Too, when I view a photo in Photoshop with the color mode on the monitor set up to Adobe RGB and the ICC profile in color direction set up to Adobe RGB 1998 information technology is less saturated that when I set the color mode on the monitor to the sRGB and the color management ICC profile to sRGB IEC61966-ii.ane. Shouldn’t it exist the other way around?

I have gone through the calibration process using Palette Chief Element and my Xrite i1 display pro. I have done information technology set for adobe RGB and assigned the the results to scale 1 and as well done it set for sRGB and assigned the results to calibration 2. When viewing a photo in Photoshop with setting calibration 1 in color style on the monitor and setting the corresponding ICC profile in color management and also viewing the same photo setting scale 2 in colour mode on the monitor and setting the corresponding ICC profile in color management, it looks very similar and in both cases is less saturated than the default settings I described in the paragraph to a higher place. Is this how it should exist? I made sure the restart photoshop each fourth dimension I fabricated a change.

Cheers in advance for your help!

Karen

ANSWER:

This question has non been answered yet.

Wide Gamut BenQ Monitor – some questions

You make very good points Karen.

As a new owner of a BenQ 270 I would also like clarification on these matters. Regrettable the user manual avoids mentioning those points, and their website is nearly useless for additional information.

If anybody can describe a uncomplicated way to switch the system level profile when changing calibration modes I would be grateful.

From what I empathize switching the organization level profiles is a simple affair on the Eizo brand, but not so on my Benq. I am starting to regret not spending the actress money for an Eizo.

I don’t want to be totally negative considering I am really happy with the image and build quality. Simply the documentation and user functionality does not seem to be up to the same standard.

-Roy Sletcher-

Re: Wide Gamut BenQ Monitor – some questions

Roy Sletcher wrote:

You make very good points Karen.

As a new possessor of a BenQ 270 I would also like description on these matters. Regrettable the user transmission avoids mentioning those points, and their website is most useless for additional information.

If everyone can describe a unproblematic way to switch the system level contour when changing calibration modes I would be grateful.

From what I understand switching the system level profiles is a uncomplicated affair on the Eizo brand, but not so on my Benq. I am starting to regret not spending the extra money for an Eizo.

I don’t want to be totally negative because I am actually happy with the image and build quality. But the documentation and user functionality does not seem to exist upward to the aforementioned standard.

-Roy Sletcher-

I have a Benq SW271 and an Eizo CS2420 next on my desk-bound.  Yes, the Eizo is a fleck higher quality.  The Eizo ColorNavigator software is much improve than Benq’southward Palette Master, but both are very usable.

Changing the colour space of a monitor is a bit of a chore.  You have to change the monitor’s colour space, and modify the monitor contour (the Eizo software tin can do both in a couple of clicks).  For most software yous must also go out and restart the programme, and generally the program reads the monitor profile only when it starts (I learned today that Photoshop checks for a alter in monitor profile in existent time).

I generally calibrate my monitors to their native colour space and leave them there.  If I desire to run into what an image looks like on an sRGB color space monitor, I use soft proofing, which is much easier.

— hide signature —

Simon

Re: Wide Gamut BenQ Monitor…

kcmortenson wrote:

I have a BenQ SW2700PT and am wondering what switching between the color mode on the bodily monitor does. I know that in club to change a color space, I need to change the color style on the monitor itself and likewise change the default ICC profile in my color management settings. I as well sympathise, I hope correctly that my color managed software uses the ICC profile as a sort of translator for color, only I’m at a loss to sympathise what the part of the color mode on the monitor itself is.

Changing the color mode of the monitor with internal 3D LUTs such equally the Benq SW2700PT changes the colour space of the monitor.

In reality, the colour space of the monitor is fixed, every bit information technology is with any monitor, determined by dyes and pigments in the screen. That’s the monitor’s native colour space. What happens is that the monitor can emulate other color spaces, provided the colours of those other colour spaces are entirely contained inside the monitor’due south native colour infinite.

A contour isn’t really a translator, it’s a description of a colour space by defining the RGB primaries in terms of one of the CIE colour spaces (which are standards).

A color managed program looks up the monitor profile, and from that deduces the colour infinite of the monitor.

On a very bones level, if I press the buttons on the bottom of my monitor and cull the default Adobe RGB and and then get into my color management settings on my computer and choose ICC profile Adobe RGB 1998, what is the monitor function doing? Is it that the ICC contour tells Photoshop how to translate and the color mode of the monitor tells the monitor to translate?

As well, when I view a photo in Photoshop with the color mode on the monitor gear up to Adobe RGB and the ICC profile in color management prepare to Adobe RGB 1998 it is less saturated that when I set up the color way on the monitor to the sRGB and the color management ICC contour to sRGB IEC61966-ii.1. Shouldn’t it be the other way around?

When you modify the colour space of the monitor and change the Windows default monitor contour, then the color saturation shouldn’t change (except for very saturated colours). If the monitor is in sRGB mode (it is emulating sRGB colour space) and has the Windows monitor profile set to sRGB, then Photoshop translates each pixel from the ProPhoto RGB value to the equivalent sRGB value for the same colour. The monitor should display the correct colour. Ditto for Adobe RGB, which should display the same colour.

With correct color management (a colour managed program and a monitor profile that matches the monitor colour space) then images should appear identical whether the monitor is sRGB or Adobe RGB. The just difference should exist for pixels with highly saturated colours that are exterior sRGB color space, which will look more saturated in Adobe RGB mode.

I accept gone through the calibration process using Palette Master Element and my Xrite i1 display pro. I have done it fix for adobe RGB and assigned the the results to calibration one and as well done it set up for sRGB and assigned the results to calibration 2. When viewing a photograph in Photoshop with setting calibration 1 in colour way on the monitor and setting the corresponding ICC profile in color management and besides viewing the same photo setting calibration 2 in color mode on the monitor and setting the respective ICC contour in color management, it looks very similar and in both cases is less saturated than the default settings I described in the paragraph above. Is this how information technology should be? I made certain the restart photoshop each time I fabricated a change.

I think I’ve misunderstood, equally this para seems to describe the same matter to me as the previous one. Can you aid me understand the difference?

Thank you in advance for your help!

Karen

— hide signature —

Simon

Re: Wide Gamut BenQ Monitor – some questions

Simon Garrett wrote:

Roy Sletcher wrote:

You make very skillful points Karen.

As a new owner of a BenQ 270 I would also like description on these matters. Regrettable the user manual avoids mentioning those points, and their website is virtually useless for additional information.

If anybody can describe a simple way to switch the system level profile when changing calibration modes I would be grateful.

From what I sympathise switching the arrangement level profiles is a simple matter on the Eizo make, but non so on my Benq. I am starting to regret non spending the extra coin for an Eizo.

I don’t desire to exist totally negative because I am really happy with the image and build quality. But the documentation and user functionality does not seem to be upwards to the aforementioned standard.

-Roy Sletcher-

I take a Benq SW271 and an Eizo CS2420 side past side on my desk. Yes, the Eizo is a bit higher quality. The Eizo ColorNavigator software is much better than Benq’southward Palette Primary, but both are very usable.

Changing the colour space of a monitor is a bit of a chore. Y’all accept to change the monitor’south color space, and alter the monitor contour (the Eizo software can do both in a couple of clicks). For most software y’all must also exit and restart the programme, and generally the program reads the monitor profile only when information technology starts (I learned today that Photoshop checks for a change in monitor contour in real time).

I generally calibrate my monitors to their native colour space and exit them there. If I desire to come across what an image looks like on an sRGB color space monitor, I apply soft proofing, which is much easier.

Simon,

Cheers for your annotate and guidance. I will follow your communication and profile for use in native fashion, and so use soft proofing every bit a means of viewing images in alternative color spaces.

Not what I expected given Benq’south publicity and advertizement. I expected manner changes would exist merely effected past using the supplied hardware puck, which is unsaid in their publicity and advertising. Possibly I was naive. Probably too much to await firmware updates or improvements to change this situation.

The above comments notwithstanding I am happy and impressed with the paradigm quality and build quality. Merely wish I had been aware of the mode change drawback at time of buy.  It may or may not have effected my decision.

-Roy Sletcher-

ppage

ppage •

Senior Member

• Posts: 2,377

ArtIsRight YouTube channel.


3

Fine art Suwansang, a BenQ colorati, has a YouTube channel with a lot of proficient videos covering the proper calibration of BenQ monitors and other related topics. I posted a question in one case to 1 of his videos last twelvemonth and he was extremely helpful.  In fact he wasn’t sure almost something so he checked it out with the BenQ engineers and got back to me a couple of days after.  For anyone with a BenQ monitor his channel is an invaluable resource.

https://world wide web.youtube.com/channel/UCWEYAVNm0jI5az9MjR9SoHw/videos

Peter

ArtIsRight

Re: Wide Gamut BenQ Monitor


2

kcmortenson wrote:

I have a BenQ SW2700PT and am wondering what switching betwixt the color mode on the bodily monitor does. I know that in guild to alter a color space, I demand to change the color manner on the monitor itself and also change the default ICC profile in my color management settings. I besides understand, I hope correctly that my color managed software uses the ICC profile equally a sort of translator for color, simply I’one thousand at a loss to understand what the role of the colour manner on the monitor itself is.

Hullo Karen,

Let me try to help you lot out. Yous are on the right though process then yes when you change the Color Fashion on the BenQ you are supposed to change the icc profile output on your figurer too.

The build in color mode on all of the BenQ SW lines are there for a few reasons:

i. It is designed for those that desire to employ the monitor right abroad without calibrating it. Would this provide the all-time consequence, non really, but it will come close. What you lot have to realize is that when BenQ Calibrate these preset color manner from the factory they are calibrated to the reference value but all of our calculator are not output reference value. In fact some can exist actually far from it, which is why I always recommend calibrating your display with your computer using Palette Chief Element (PME).

2. These color modes are each calibrate with the reference gamut parameter for the corresponding color infinite. So for Adobe RGB color manner, images are going to await more saturated than sRGB considering it is displaying a larger colour space. Again these can be used for a crude reference.

3. Though the color may non be as correct, y’all can quickly change between these color modes using your custom calibrated icc profile to rapidly gage what the image would look like in the other colour space. All of the display visitor that makes pro or pro-sumer displays include these modes. They may non exist included for the right reasons but it is a fashion for them to set departure color response based on the colour space gamut.

On a very basic level, if I press the buttons on the lesser of my monitor and choose the default Adobe RGB and so go into my color direction settings on my computer and choose ICC profile Adobe RGB 1998, what is the monitor part doing? Is information technology that the ICC profile tells Photoshop how to interpret and the color mode of the monitor tells the monitor to translate?

This said, if yous use any of these colour modes and pick the corresponding icc profile on your calculator, amazingly enough your color won’t be displayed correctly. And this comes down to your video card, none of them and truly output reference color. So when you are choosing the Adobe RGB icc on your computer, those are standard reference contour, however, the contour is not turned to your videocard output, hence y’all are outputting some variation of Adobe RGB and not the reference Adobe RGB.

This icc contour on the computer is the one that Photoshop is using to do color conversion. However, every bit I said in the paragraph above, since the colour are non out putting correctly already, in this case photoshop would exist doing further conversion on an wrong output.

Also, when I view a photo in Photoshop with the colour mode on the monitor set to Adobe RGB and the ICC profile in color direction set to Adobe RGB 1998 it is less saturated that when I prepare the color mode on the monitor to the sRGB and the color direction ICC contour to sRGB IEC61966-2.1. Shouldn’t information technology be the other way around?

No, what yous are experiencing is correct.Based on my answer above, the standard Adobe RGB or sRGB icc profile should never be selected equally the display contour. These are generic profile that does not take into account the brandish capability, parameter and gamut. So when you gear up your screen contour to sRGB, your system in doing conversion on the dorsum stop in real time and what it is trying to do with sRGB is convert up the smaller color infinite to fit the wide gamut of the display. This does not happen in Adobe RGB because the display is broad gamut already, and so in that location are some minor colour adjustments simply no color conversion or scaling involved. It is the conversion from a smaller profile to a larger gamut display that is causing this issue.

I have gone through the calibration procedure using Palette Principal Element and my Xrite i1 display pro. I have done it fix for adobe RGB and assigned the the results to calibration 1 and also done it set for sRGB and assigned the results to calibration 2. When viewing a photo in Photoshop with setting calibration 1 in color mode on the monitor and setting the corresponding ICC profile in color management and also viewing the same photo setting calibration 2 in colour style on the monitor and setting the respective ICC profile in color management, it looks very similar and in both cases is less saturated than the default settings I described in the paragraph higher up. Is this how it should be? I made sure the restart photoshop each time I made a change.

The procedure that you described above is the best way to do it. The less saturated color that you see is the nigh correct color that you can become out of your system. Personally, my recommendation is to but calibrate your display using either Adobe RGB or Panel Native in PME, gear up information technology to slot 1 and just use that to do everything. If you ever need to run into what the colour will expect like in sRGB then you lot tin can calibrate slot 2 to sRGB but in my fifteen+ years doing color management, using it in my workflow and teaching. I have not done it myself.

If y’all like I fabricated a guide on how to all-time calibrate your SW2700PT using PME latest version 1.iii.8 and Panel Native setting. Yous can check it out here https://youtu.be/bz9y3db9vRI

Thanks in advance for your assist!

I hope that all of this helps.

Karen